The plaintiffs were shafiq rasul, asif iqbal, and rhuhel ahmed, three friends from a workingclass town in england who have come to be known as the tipton. Even after this court reversed al odah on statutory grounds and held that detainees at guantanamo bay could seek habeas relief under 28 u. District court on behalf of hicks, rasul, and iqbal the habeas petition challenges the presidential executive order of november, 2001, which authorized indefinite detention without due process of law. Bush and a companion case will be announced by justice stevens. Mar 04, 20 petitioners reply that any argument that the relief they seek is foreclosed by the separation of powers does not survive rasul v. Treatment of battlefield detainees in the war on terrorism. Bush, that foreign enemy combatants held at guantanamo bay naval station had a right to challenge the legality of their. George walker bush, president of the united states, et al. Both consumers and legal professionals can find answers, insights, and updates in the blogs listed below. Summary and analysis of opinions related to detainees in.
On writ of certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the district of columbia. Stevens, john paul, and supreme court of the united states. Petitioner shafiq rasul and asif iqbal are citizens of the united kingdom and are presently held in respondents custody at the united states naval base at guantanamo bay, cuba. United states district court for the district of columbia civil action no. Petitioners cases were then consolidated into two proceedings. Berensont i am going to focus my remarks this morning primarily on one of the three major enemy combatant decisions that the u. The main issue was to determine the courts of the united states had any. The next friends bringing the petition are the father of an. Other detainees, invoking the jurisdictional provisions of. Audio transcription for oral argument april 20, 2004 in rasul v. In that case, several guantanamo detainees had filed a petition for habeas corpus seeking release from custody, access to counsel, freedom from interrogations, and other relief.
Naval base in guantanamo bay, cuba, brought several suits to contest the. Petitioners shafiq rasul and asif iqbal were recently designated for release to the custody of great britain although they remain at guantanamo pending release. Syllabus opinion stevens concurrence kennedy dissent scalia html version pdf version. Us supreme court hears arguments on habeas corpus for. Argued april 20, 2004decided june 28, 2004 pursuant to congress joint resolution authorizing the use of necessary. Petitioner shafiq rasul and asif iqbal are citizens. Supreme court20080822 rasul petition for certiorari. In august 2004, rasul, asif iqbal, and ruhal ahmed, all from tipton, compiled a report on their abuse and humiliation while in us custody. Bush, which extended the right of habeas corpus to noncitizen.
Us administrative procedure act, chapter 5 of title 5 of the us code. Bush was the first case concerning suspensions of basic liberties in relation to the post911 terrorism conflict to be heard. As will be told in this essay, the story reveals the intriguing extent to which stevenss work in ahrens over fifty years ago influenced the reasoning, if not the result, in rasul. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. He was released in march 2004, shortly after his return to the united kingdom, more than three months before rasul v.
United states courts have jurisdiction to consider challenges to the legality of the detention of foreign nationals captured. A the district court has jurisdiction to hear petitioners. Bush 503 worth in rasul, is a remarkable one in supreme court history. By failing to recognize the challenges facing political and military leaders in the wake of the september 11, 2001 attacks, in reversing fiftyfour years of precedent relied upon by the executive branch, and in. The courts 63 judgment on june 28, 2004, reversed a d. With respect to the habeas claims, we held that no court in this. Rumsfeld was part of ccrs broader efforts to end indefinite detention without charge or trial, achieve a just closure of guantanamo, and ensure accountability for u. Shafiq rasul, skina bibi, as next friend of shafiq rasul, et al. Jul 01, 2014 ten years ago saturday, the supreme court ruled, in rasul v. As a result of the 2004 supreme court decision rasul v.
District court on behalf of hicks, rasul, and iqbal the habeas petition challenges the presidential executive order of november, 2001, which. Bush audio transcription for opinion announcement june 28, 2004 in rasul v. As will be told in this essay, the story reveals the intriguing. In that case, several guantanamo detainees had filed a petition for habeas corpus seeking release from custody, access to counsel, freedom from. Padilla,3 rasul is the case that will affect the most people and most affect future governmental operations. Petitioner david hicks, an australian, has been designated by the president under the november, 2001 military order. In early 2002, the center for constitutional rights ccr was the first organization to file two habeas corpus petitions, rasul v. In the first, the district judge granted the governments motion to.
The purpose of holding the prisoners at guantanamo bay was and is to put them beyond the rule of law, beyond. Fawzi khalid abdullah fahad al odah and the 11 other. Us alien tort claims act, section 50 of title 28 of the us code. Both consumers and legal professionals can find answers, insights, and updates in the blogs listed. Well hear 4 argument now on 03334, shafiq rasul vs. Findlaw legal blogs findlaws legal blogs bring you access to the latest legal news and information. A case in which the court ruled that united states courts have jurisdiction to consider legal appeals filed on behalf of foreign citizens held by the united states military in guantanamo bay naval base, cuba. The federal trial court dismissed this case for lack of jurisdiction. Video case which group is particularly concerned that valued american freedoms will be sacrificed in the interest of national safety. Shafiq rasul born april 15, 1977 in dudley, west midlands, england is best known for being a detainee held at guantanamo bay by the united states, which treated him an unlawful combatant. Jonakait introduction of the three recent supreme court cases concerning enemy combatants, hamdi v. The latter decision reversed the holding of the court of appeals for the district of columbia circuit, which had agreed with the bush administration that no u. Certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the district of columiba circuit no.
Rasul v bush pdf syllabus connection with hostilities and incarcerated at guantanamo bay. The latest versions of adobe reader do not support viewing pdf files within firefox on mac os and if you are using a modern intel mac, there is no. Get free access to the complete judgment in rasul v. For a summary of rasul and related cases, see crs report rs21884, the supreme court 2003 term. Because modern specialists in violence constantly seek new and unexpected ways of defeating adversaries, the codified body of the law of armed conflict always lags at least a generation behind. Petitioner shafiq rasul and asif iqbal are citizens of the united kingdom and are presently held in respondents custody at the united states naval base at guantanamo. Bush facts in 2001, two cases were presented by justice stevens in the opinion court of the usa. The main issue was to determine the courts of the united states had any problem of lawful imprisonment of the foreigners who were arrested.
The supreme court in rasul concluded, albeit in dictum, that, in light of the particular circumstances surrounding their imprisonment, the guantanamo. Rasul was the lead plaintiff in ccrs landmark supreme court case rasul v. Bush2 that federal courts have jurisdiction to hear habeas petitions by or on behalf of such detainees. In the first, the district judge granted the governments motion to dismiss, holding that the detainees had no rights that could be vindi together with no. Bush,5 holding that the federal habeas statute, 28 u. Bush, which extended the right of habeas corpus to noncitizen detainees held overseas, the united states congress passed the military commissions act of 2006 mca. Naval base in guantanamo bay, cuba, brought several suits to contest the legality and conditions of their confinement.
786 802 1350 1453 1306 4 265 317 1179 1320 697 1203 1283 1453 439 1423 494 1007 624 397 1192 434 352 66 146 1294 142 335 657 599 121 1265 1328 438 50 1025 415 1435 795 1242 1362